… that Masa is just a little bit country, and Monster a little bit rock ‘n’ roll.
That, at least, was one of my first thoughts when enjoying Mayday’s latest album, Poetry of the Day After. Masa’s composition “More than Surviving, Less than Living (生存以上 生活以下 ),” is an improvement over his effort on the last album, “Most Important Trivial Concern (最重要的小事),” but it has a decided twang to it, I think. And somehow, I feel like I hear that twang even transferred to Ashin’s singing.
So. I’ve been putting this off, the “what did I think of the new album” post. This is mostly because I thought I liked Born to Love:
I’ve only listened to the album twice now, but already I like it better than All God’s Children Can Dance (神的孩子都在跳舞) - it seems a bit more polished, and I like the orchestration. So far, my least favorite track is “Offering to Heaven (寵上天)” (a.k.a. “Baby”), which I think in places too closely resembles “Life is Troubled Times (亂世浮水)” and another song I’ve not yet managed to single out…. Also, I’m still uncertain about the Mandopop version of “Ode to Joy” (”快樂很偉大”) as well - is it well done? Was it even necessary? I’m not sure.
Okay, I still don’t much care for “Offering to Heaven” or “Happiness is Grand,” but what I didn’t realize when I wrote that was that would be pretty much the only two times I would listen to that album. Oh sure, I dragged it out again right before the Toronto concert to review a bit, but by then I was decidedly lukewarm on it, and I pretty much never listen to it or, to be painfully honest, any of the individual songs on it. I rarely ever listen to All God’s Children either, but there I’ll at least drag out “Sun Wu Kong” or “Good Night Earthlings” now and again. I think the problem, in my very uneducated opinion, is that too much of those albums consists of pretty generic karaoke songs. Anyway, this time I wanted to wait a while after I had the album to comment on it so I could see if those first impressions held.
Key thing to note, though: this isn’t really a review, just random thoughts on the album. I’m trying to write an actual review and struggling with it; if I finish it, I’ll let you know.
The number one difference between this album and the last two for me is that this one has songs I get “stuck” on - I get to the end and think, “okay, I just need to hear that *one* more time.” And then again. And maybe once more. For me, those songs are “Liver-busting (爆肝),” “The Yet Unbroken Part of My Heart (我心中尚未崩壞的地方),” and “Interview with the Vampire (夜訪吸血鬼)”… but especially “The Yet Unbroken Part of My Heart.” I wouldn’t claim that it is necessarily the best song on the album, but I am a sucker for anything in 3/4 or 6/8 time (it started with The Beatles “You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away” and is one reason I love Peng Tan so much), and I adore the lyrics (though I’m not done editing them yet). Okay, admittedly I don’t relate to the difficulties of camera lenses and competing or chart positions, but I think you can treat that as a metaphor and translate it into anything you struggle with. Seriously, I could probably listen to this song over and over again… for a while anyway.
“Liver-Busting” starts off sounding like a Jonny Lang song and then turns into sort of a cross between Michael Jackson and Prince - but with a Mayday flourish (not least of all in the choice of “Liver Busting” for the title - this might well be Ashin’s most autobiographical song to date). The song really works for me, even if I’m already giggling at all the possibilities for Ashin forgetting these lyrics in concert.
“Interview with a Vampire” is jazzy and marvelous (though in classic Ashin manner, it has some pretty dark lyrics, vampire campiness notwithstanding): it feels very different from their standard style, but is somehow still quintessentially Mayday. (Write more songs, Guanyou!) The only thing is that it sounds like Ashin’s voice cracks on the “The night is my cover (夜色就是我的披肩)” - I don’t know quite to make of it, but it always distracts me for a second before I turn back to the song. It’s interesting in light of the fact that overall Ashin’s technique as a singer has improved by leaps and bounds since the band’s early days, but these little traces of the old Ashin come through all the same.
My two least favorite songs on the album are “OMG (噢買尬)” and “The Song of Laughter and Forgetting (笑忘歌)” - “OMG” because it’s pretty generic, and even sounds like “Many Thanks” remade as a more upbeat track (maybe I’m alone in this, because it’s not like it’s the same, but this song always makes my mind jump to the rather forgettable Taiwanese track), and “The Song of Laughter and Forgetting” because it sounds exactly like what it is: an advertising song. After each round of the chorus, I expect a deep, booming voice to cut in with, “Buy Extra Sugar Free Gum! It’s the mintiest…” (Yes, I realize the song is used for advertising Hey Song Sarsaparilla, not gum, but that’s what my brain always seems to be expecting.)
I actually quite like “Like Smoke (如煙 ),” even though every time I sit in my office and listen to it I get fooled into thinking someone is at more door calling me about two minutes in, along with “Poetry of the Day After (後青春期的詩)” (which I’ve taken to singing in the shower - how’s that for a recommendation?). My opinion of “Suddenly Missing You (突然好想你)” changes as I listen to it; I’m usually not that enthusiastic as it starts off, but by the time it builds I’m in full monster-ballad mode and pretty happy with it (and let’s be honest here, who *doesn’t* relate to those lyrics?). “Spring’s Scream (春天的吶喊)” is a great song to run to, and a necessary counterbalance to the more ballad-like tracks on the second half of the album. What’s left? Oh, my (good) opinions of “Breakthrough Day (出頭天)” (which gets a few automatic bonus points for being in Hokkien) and “You’re Not Truly Happy (你不是真正的快樂 )” are already on record, I think.
The sum total is that this is an album I’ve already listened to many, many more times than the previous two (put together), which is pretty high praise. Not perfect, but definitely no disappointment for me. And you?
So? What did you think of Mayday's seventh album?
Update: See, this is why I try not to have my own opinions about Mayday albums. The review I’ve been waiting for from Steve is now up at MaydayBlue. Inevitably all my opinions about these songs will now start subconsciously changing…. (Though I sorta suspect I’m never going to love “The Song of Laughter and Forgetting,” no matter what anyone says about it. The booming advertising voice in my head just keeps interrupting and ruining it for me.)
Update2: I just noticed the poll says “started December 19,” even though I posted it last night (Dec. 28). That’s because that’s how long ago I created the poll, then sat on this post changing my mind about what to put in it. For all that angst you’d think I’d have better insights, but such is life.